Natalie Sansivero and Jerome Williams Identified as Victims in Fatal Upper Niagara River Boat Crash

Grand Island, NY – July 24, 2024 — A devastating boating accident on the Upper Niagara River has claimed the lives of two beloved individuals, 46-year-old Natalie Sansivero of Grand Island, New York, and 66-year-old Jerome Williams of Buffalo. The tragedy unfolded late Tuesday evening, July 23, when their vessel struck a concrete abutment just north of Navy Island, causing them to be ejected into the river.

According to an official press release from the New York State Park Police, Niagara County 911 received a distress call at approximately 9:40 p.m. regarding a possible vessel accident on the Upper Niagara River. The initial report indicated that a boat had collided with a structure in the water and that both occupants were missing.

Massive Multi-Agency Search Effort Launched

In response, a large-scale emergency operation was launched involving multiple agencies. Among those who responded with marine and aviation resources were:

• New York State Park Police
• Niagara County Sheriff’s Office
• Erie County Sheriff’s Office
• United States Coast Guard
• Town and City of Tonawanda Police
• Grand Island Fire Company
• River Road Fire Department
• Erie County Air 1
• Niagara County Aviation Unit
• City of Tonawanda Marine Unit
• North Tonawanda Professional Firefighters Local 1333

Despite extensive search efforts that lasted into the early morning hours, neither Natalie Sansivero nor Jerome Williams was located during the initial operation. Authorities suspended the search around 3:00 a.m. due to limited visibility and resumed it again at daybreak on Wednesday.

Boat Recovered, Investigation Underway

The vessel involved in the incident was found to be extensively damaged and has since been recovered and towed by the New York State Park Police for further investigation. Officials have confirmed that the New York State Police Bureau of Criminal Investigation (BCI) is actively involved in reconstructing the accident to determine the precise cause.

Authorities are urging any witnesses or individuals with information related to the accident to come forward. Anyone who may have observed the vessel before or during the time of the crash is encouraged to contact State Park Police Niagara Headquarters at (716) 278-1777.

Victims Identified: Remembering Natalie Sansivero and Jerome Williams

The two victims have now been publicly identified. Natalie Sansivero, 46, of Grand Island, was a well-known and well-loved member of her community. Described by friends and family as compassionate, full of life, and devoted to those around her, Natalie’s sudden passing has left an irreplaceable void.

Jerome Williams, 66, of Buffalo, was equally cherished by his family and community. Known for his generous heart, wisdom, and deep love for the outdoors, Jerome was a figure who inspired respect and admiration from all who knew him.

Together, they were enjoying what should have been a peaceful and relaxing evening on the river — a reminder of how quickly life can change in the blink of an eye.

Community Reaction and Mourning

News of the fatal boat crash has sent shockwaves throughout Western New York, particularly in the communities of Grand Island and Buffalo, where both Natalie and Jerome had strong roots. Vigils, memorial posts, and heartfelt messages are flooding social media as friends, neighbors, and loved ones attempt to process the enormity of this loss.

Local officials have extended their condolences and are urging boaters across the region to exercise extreme caution, especially when operating vessels at night or in areas where visibility is reduced.

“This is an unimaginable tragedy,” said one Grand Island resident. “Natalie and Jerome were both incredible people who brought light into the lives of those around them. This loss is just devastating.”

Safety Reminder for Boaters

The accident has sparked a renewed conversation around boating safety on the Niagara River and throughout the region. Law enforcement and safety officials are reminding boaters of several key practices:

• Avoid nighttime boating unless absolutely necessary
• Always wear a life jacket
• Stay alert for obstructions and hazards in the water
• Avoid high speeds in unfamiliar or poorly lit areas
• Carry emergency signaling devices on board

This tragic event underscores the importance of vigilance, preparation, and caution when enjoying recreational activities on the water.

Final Thoughts

The deaths of Natalie Sansivero and Jerome Williams serve as a heartbreaking reminder of the fragility of life and the risks associated with waterway navigation. As their families grieve and the investigation continues, the entire Western New York community stands in solidarity with those affected by this tragedy.

Funeral arrangements and memorial services for both Natalie and Jerome will be announced in the coming days, as their loved ones begin the difficult process of honoring their memory and saying goodbye.

For those wishing to share information about the accident or support the families, please contact the New York State Park Police at the Niagara Headquarters:
Phone: 716-278-1777
Address: 570 Whirlpool Street, Niagara Falls, NY 14301.